This is the page the launched the 2013-2014 Blogging Archaeology Blog Carnival. Don’t know what it is? Read on. The event is over and has accumulated in a wonderful book:
It is Open Access i.e. FREE to Read. You can download it here: Blogging Archaeology. It is a great resource to learn about blogging in archaeology. If you want to learn more about the carnival that started it all read on-
At this year’s SAA conference there is going to be an amazing Blogging in Archaeology session. It has been a few years since there has been one. Unfortunately, I won’t be able to attend the session and I know a couple of other archaeology bloggers who can’t either. My way of contributing is to widen the participation by hosting a blogging carnival (what’s a blogging carnival, click here) on archaeology and blogging. This was done for the last blogging session by Colleen and this is inspired by her work.
It works like this:
- Each month leading up to the SAAs I will post a question. If you would like to answer this question, blog about it. Tell us your thoughts and opinions. Please steal the banner above, and link back to this post (wordpress alerts me to links).
- Also, email me (drocksmacqueen@gmail.com) or post the link in the comments (either here or the post with the questions on it). This is so I know about your post and can link to it.
- At the end of the month, I will summarize all of the post and add links so that folks can find them all in one place. Hopefully, this will allow us to highlight some great archaeology blogs.
- EDIT– Kelly asked- ‘Is there any obligation to take part every month?’ Absolutely not, take part as many or as few times as you want. If there is a question you really like, blog about it. If it does not particularly interest you, wait till the next month. It is all up to you.
- EDIT– You do not have to be interested in going to the SAAs or an American to participate. We want everyone who blogs or who are interested in blogging to participate, regardless of geographic location.
Ideally, this carnival will run till the SAAs in 2014. Participate as many or as few times as you like, it is 100% voluntary. I realize everyone is very busy but if you have a moment to blog we would love to get your input. To quote Colleen from the last Carnival,
“The more people we hear from, the better! There are so many great archaeology blogs out there that don’t get enough readership, hopefully this will bring a few of them to light.”
We have a twitter hashtag- #blogarch please use it for the carnival and SAA session. Thanks.
Responses so far (it is not too late to respond to these months)-
Final Question
Next month is the SAA session on blogging so this will be the final question for #blogarch. Learning from my mistakes this will be an actual question this time.
The last question is where are you/we going with blogging or would you it like to go? I leave it up to you to choose between reflecting on you and your blog personally or all of archaeology blogging/bloggers or both. Tells us your goals for blogging. Or if you have none why that is? Tell us the direction that you hope blogging takes in archaeology.
Short and simple and I hope a good question to finish off #BlogArch with.
- Let Chris know by March 5th if you are interested in participating
- Papers are due April 5th, email them to Chris at chriswebster@digtech-llc.com
-
Put in as many graphics as you want. It’s an eBook so in this particular case, size doesn’t matter! Please ensure that you have permission to use the images
- Because it is an e-book there is no real limit in terms of length but don’t go crazy, we would like to keep it under 6000 words but longer pieces are ok if you let us know in advance. It can be as short as a blog post too
- Use the Harvard referencing system
- Style- write in whatever style you want, 1st person casual or 3rd person academic it does not matter. British English, American English, German, etc. it does not matter but please stay consistent.
- There will be an editorial review but no peer review
- It can be on any subject related to Archaeology and Blogging. It can be a full referenced examination of a topic or a personal narrative. It can be a photo essay too. There is no limitation to how you write your piece.
Also, Colleen Morgan is putting together a special peer reviewed issue of Internet Archaeology on Archaeology and Blogging. For more information about the dedicated issue of Internet Archaeology, please contact Colleen Morgan (colleen.morgan@york.ac.uk) by 10 Feb. That date is key as spaces for the IA issue are limited and Colleen needs to know if you are interested right away. Those papers need to follow IA standards and how to write for IA can be found here.
So what does the e-book and IA special issue have to do with the carnival? Well this months question is open. That is you can blog about any subject you want relating to Archaeology and Blogging, Blogging Archaeology, Archaeology Blogging, or however you want to term it.
The reason for this is because throughout the carnival many of you have mentioned using a blog as a way to work through your thoughts, some on the way to writing longer pieces. We are hoping that you might want to blog about a subject that you would then turn into a piece for the e-book or IA issue i.e. Blog post to e-book chapter to peer-reviewed journal article.
So feel free to choose any topic relating to Archaeology and Blogging and blog about it for this months carnival. Maybe considered submitting it or turning into a longer piece for the e-book or IA issue? Or NOT. I don’t want to turn this into a chore so feel free to just blog about whatever, there is no pressure to make it anything more than a blog post. We will return to a defined question for March but we thought to get this out so people have enough time to put together something for IA or the e-book. If you have any questions let me know- drocksmacqueen@gmail.com
January
What are your best (or if you want your worst) post(s) and why? Compare and contrast your different bests/worsts.
I leave it up to you to define what best is. We bloggers have all sorts of different stats available to us. You could look at-
- Most viewed -single day?, week? month? year? all time- I leave it up to you
- Most individual views
- Most diverse audience
- Facebook likes
- Most viral (however you define viral)
- Most Tweets
- Went viral on reddit
Or you could go a bit more qualitative-
- Best conversations
- Led to a talk or a paper
- Personal favorites (again however you determine that)
- Most proud of
- Best comment left by your audience e.g. this post changed my life,
These are just some ideas to get people started but please use what ever criteria you want e.g. post with the most mentions of the word mummy, post your mom liked the best. Use 0ne or 20 different criteria it is up to you. Compare and contrast two posts or 200, again it is up to you.
John’s response to December’s question is a good example- “My most popular post, which detailed some of the section 106 process and talked about how sites are both a dream and a nightmare, has 390 views. My favorite post has 113.”
The idea for this month is simple- reflect on what you consider you best post(s) and why that is. Also, think about what others might think is your best post however you want to measure that (views? comments? etc.). Then share your thoughts.
December
Please, please blog about the past months questions. We only do it my months to move the carnival forward but there is nothing to stop you from blogging previous questions. Blog and send me the link and I will add you to the final post.
The theme is the good, the bad, and the ugly of blogging. Blog about one or all of these themes. Instructions on how to participate can be found here.
The Good- what has been good about blogging. I know some people in their ‘why blogging’ posts mentioned creating networks and getting asked to talk on a subject. But take this to the next level, anything and everything positive about blogging, share your stories. You could even share what you hope blogging will do for you in the future.
The Bad- lots of people mention it feels like talking to brick wall sometimes when you blog. No one comments on posts or very few people do. What are your disappointments with blogging? What are your frustrations? What do you hate about blogging? What would you like to see changed about blogging?
The Ugly- I know Chris at RAS will mention the time he got fired for blogging about archaeology. It is your worst experiences with blogging- trolls, getting fired, etc.
New to Blogging? Now I know some of the participants have only been blogging for a few weeks and PLEASE join in. You may not have had any good or bad experiences but we would love to hear about your hopes and dreams/ concerns and nightmares about your future blogging experiences.
The idea is that these are general themes to guide you. Looking through the different responses to the last set of questions I see a huge range in how people responded. Please respond to these themes however you want. I will be collecting up the responses on January 3rd and do this all over again.
Please link your responses to Decembers questions to this post/comment there or email me at drocksmacqueen@gmail.com with your links so I can collect them at the end of the month.
November
Is actually two and half questions, feel free to answer one or both.
Why blogging? – Why did you, or if it was a group- the group, start a blog? Feel free to take this an any direction you want.
I realize that lots of people have already done a post like this (still please post the link here or send me the link if you have already blogged about this). So in case you don’t want to write this post again here is a second(ish) question. (Again, still send me the link or post it below).
Why are you still blogging?- Some prompting question along those lines: Have the reasons why changed since you first started blogging? Are there new reasons why you blog?
Now I am know I am asking a lot here but the flip to that question is- Why have you stopped blogging? I know there are lots of bloggers out there who have stopped blogging regularly or at all. It would be great to hear the reasons why. The irony of asking people who stopped blogging to blog about why they stopped is not lost on me. But if you are willing to share through one last post or maybe send me an email that I can re-post here, please?
PS if anyone wants to host one of these monthly sessions drop me a line.
Spencer Carter
November 5, 2013
Great idea!
mohammednano9012@yahoo,com
December 6, 2013
very fantastic idea!
Kelly M
November 6, 2013
This is a fantastic idea. Is there any obligation to take part every month?
Doug Rocks-Macqueen
November 6, 2013
Absolutely not, take part as many or as few times as you want. If there is a question you really like, blog about it. If it does not particularly interest you, wait till the next month. It is all up to you.
Kelly M
November 6, 2013
That’s great. Thanks for organizing this, Doug. I’m looking forward to seeing what fellow archaeology bloggers have to say. 🙂
Kelly M
November 6, 2013
I can see that there’s a trackback to my post but in case you have any trouble accessing it, here’s the link to my response – http://archaeologyoftombraider.wordpress.com/2013/11/06/why-i-blog-about-archaeology/
Doug Rocks-Macqueen
November 6, 2013
I actually just followed it to your post. I am actually on your post right now and a nice thing about WP is it lets me comment back here. Brilliant stuff by the way. Ever thought of presenting your work at an archaeology conference or event? You probably do better public archaeology then most archaeologists. Your reasoning for blogging is superb!
Kelly M
November 6, 2013
Hi Doug, thanks so much for the kind words. I feel like a bit of an amateur as far as archaeology blogging goes but I’d like to think that my enthusiasm and willingness to learn is contagious. 🙂
I’ve never really considered presenting my work at a conference (I’m not sure how professionals and academics would react to me) and, to be honest, I’m painfully shy. Public speaking’s never been my forté…
Doug Rocks-Macqueen
November 6, 2013
Yeah, me too. On a side note but someone related to all this. What was the process to getting to the archaeology of tomb raider? I followed your two other blogs. Actually, I followed your first over to china heritage and now over to tomb raider. I was kind of wondering how/why you moved from blog to blog.
Kelly M
November 7, 2013
Well, my first archaeology blog, The Amateur Archaeologist, proved to be a challenge as it covered too broad a topic…so I decided to focus on Chinese archaeology for a while. I enjoyed working on that one but I ended up losing a lot of my Amateur Archaeologist readership as few of them were interested in Chinese history and heritage issues. It also took too long for me to translate articles for the blog (it was a one-person project and I could no longer fit it around a full-time job and my other hobbies) so I eventually decided to abandon it.
As for The Archaeology of Tomb Raider, the blog was something I had had in mind for a few years now but since people had gotten bored of the franchise and I wasn’t sure if fans of the games were interested in archaeology (after all, Lara Croft is a terrible archaeologist), I didn’t pursue it any further. When they released the new game, there was a sudden revival of interest in the Tomb Raider games so I thought it was the perfect time to launch the blog. I’ve had a lot of positive feedback from my readers and I now receive almost daily requests from fans for more information about the places and artworks seen in the games. It seems that it’s easier to establish yourself in the blogosphere if you’re a niche blogger…and I think I may have finally found my niche.
Doug Rocks-Macqueen
November 7, 2013
Cool, thanks. Always wondered how that happened.
Kelly M
November 8, 2013
I’m something of a perfectionist so I’m always thinking of ways to improve upon things. It’s both a strength and a weakness.. 🙂
Elizabeth
November 17, 2013
I’m not sure how other professionals would act, but I would live to see you at a conference. Perhaps some day a session can be created in which you would feel comfortable, I think you have a great deal to bring to the table in such a way that other people should pay attention especially professionals.
Elizabeth
November 18, 2013
*love (not live) 🙂
Kelly M
November 20, 2013
Thanks for your kind words, Elizabeth. I agree that a greater public involvement is needed and I’m glad to see that archaeologists and “amateurs” (such as myself) can share our thoughts and ideas via blogs, online forums and social media.
Katy Meyers
November 8, 2013
Excited to start answering these, and looking forward to the session!
SuccinctBill (@SuccinctBill)
November 12, 2013
That’s a great question, Doug. Apparently, I’m about the only archaeology blogger that hasn’t thought about why I started in the first place.
Helping other archaeologists find jobs was my initial goal when I started the Succinct Research blog. I had been reworking other folks’ resumes, but all the cheap skate archaeologists I knew weren’t willing to pay me to do that. But, the archaeologists I helped said they would be willing to pay for a book about resume writing aimed specifically at archaeologists. So, I wrote the book around the time I started the blog. I was going to offer the book for free, but I wanted to see if eBook writing could pay for the website. It can.
At some point, I realized the tips and suggestions I was putting on my blog were rarely addressed in the readings and projects we have to do in college. I also realized that there was a massive disconnect between being an actual archaeologist (CRM or academia) and what was being taught in school. In fact, most of what I learned in my BA and MA was useless for the stuff I was doing on the job as a CRMer. That’s when I realized the second goal of my blog: to help spread the kind of information that is really necessary for being an archaeologist. I also realized that I could network with other archaeology bloggers to spread the word to a wider audience. Doug and Chris Webster have been really influential in my blogging career and have helped me reach a wider audience.
My current goal is to continue creating stuff that can be used to help archaeologists in their careers. With the blog, I can quickly get the message out in my own way and in my own voice. It’s also an easy way to spread useful information. EBooks are also a great tool because they’re portable and cheap when compared with the huge costs of a paper book created by a huge publishing company. I’m also thinking about creating some trainings and MOOCs in the future, which I will obviously be blogging about.
SuccinctBill (@SuccinctBill)
November 26, 2013
I’m almost a month late, but here’s my post:
http://www.succinctresearch.com/why-i-started-blogging-about-cultural-resource-management/
Can’t wait to see what next month’s question is.
ArchyFantasies
November 14, 2013
I post because you asked.
http://archyfantasies.wordpress.com/2013/11/14/debunking-blogging-and-public-outreach-blogging-archaeology-carnival-2014/
Elizabeth
November 17, 2013
http://historyechoes.tumblr.com/post/67286167428/the-first-picture-is-a-terrible-snap-shot-of
I added my response on my tumblr which goes along with my blog HistoryEchoes.wordpress.com . I think this is great and am sad I will probably not make it to SAA.
Doug Rocks-Macqueen
November 18, 2013
Thanks for joining in!
John
November 21, 2013
If you don’t get a trackback, here’s mine:
It’s really long (big surprise there…) but great questions!
Katy Meyers
November 21, 2013
Finally got around to posting my blog answers for november: http://bonesdontlie.wordpress.com/2013/11/21/blogging-archaeology-november/
Katrin
November 25, 2013
Not sure whether you’d sort my blog as an archaeology blog or not – but here is my post:
http://togs-from-bogs.blogspot.de/2013/11/am-i-or-am-i-not-blogging-archaeology.html
Doug Rocks-Macqueen
November 25, 2013
If it helps, I do follow your blog in my archaeology bog rss feed. Thanks for participating.
Katrin
December 2, 2013
Yes, that helps – or at least it vastly pleases me : )
capmsu
November 25, 2013
Michigan State U. Campus Archaeology Program http://campusarch.msu.edu/?p=2537 blog post on “Why Blogging?”.
Doug Rocks-Macqueen
November 28, 2013
Thanks
cfeagans
November 26, 2013
I think this is a great idea! Blog carnivals seem to have fallen out of popularity of late -I was just thinking about one we used to do regularly for anthropology called the Four Stone Hearth and wondering what it might take to revive it. I’m in.
Lisa-Marie Shillito
November 26, 2013
Thank you for organising this! Here are my responses:
http://castlesandcoprolites.blogspot.co.uk/2013/11/blogging-archaeology.html
Doug Rocks-Macqueen
November 26, 2013
Thanks, for joining.
sdhaddow
November 26, 2013
Thanks for inviting me! Here’s my post:
Doug Rocks-Macqueen
November 26, 2013
Thank you.
Katharine Watson
November 26, 2013
Hi,
I think this is a great idea and I’m excited to participate, and to get the chance to learn more about about other people’s blogs and archaeology all over the world.
We started our blog earlier this year. The opening post kind of summarises why (http://blog.underoverarch.co.nz/2013/04/i-am-an-archaeologist/).
As a bit of context, I’m an archaeologist working on post-earthquake Christchurch (I worked there for about 10 years prior to that as well). The post-eq demolitions mean both a huge loss of heritage for the city, but also the recovery of a lot of archaeological material. I started the blog for a number of reasons: to show people that while we were losing so much of our built heritage, we were also gaining a lot of knowledge; to fulfill the ‘public good’ aspect of archaeology (a blog – & a Facebook page – seemed the best way & easiest to engage quickly with the public); and to show people why archaeology’s important.
It’s been a lot of work, but it’s also been really validating. The positive response we get from so many people reaffirms the importance of the work we’re doing, and that people are interested in our recent past. It’s also been a great way of connecting with descendant communities.
Doug Rocks-Macqueen
November 27, 2013
Thanks Katharine
Katy Meyers
November 26, 2013
Here’s the link for MSU Campus Archaeology’s submission to the first question: http://campusarch.msu.edu/?p=2537
Emily Johnson
November 26, 2013
LOVE THIS. Will definitely be joining in, big time. Heh… any excuse to talk about myself…
Sarah
November 27, 2013
Alright, I went ahead and wrote a post about why I don’t blog anymore, but want to. I hope someone out there enjoys it!
http://diggin-it-archaeology.blogspot.com/2013/11/blogging-archaeology-carnival-month-1.html
Doug Rocks-Macqueen
November 27, 2013
Great, adds a different perspective.
Paige Doerner
November 27, 2013
Hello! I just answered the 2 November questions on my blog, Imponderabilia. You can view them here: http://paigedoerner.wordpress.com/2013/11/27/saa-2014-blogging-archaeology-november/
Doug Rocks-Macqueen
November 27, 2013
Thanks Paige
John R. Roby
November 27, 2013
Hey folks, my contribution: http://digsanddocs.wordpress.com/2013/11/27/reflection-time-why-blog-about-archaeology/
Doug Rocks-Macqueen
November 28, 2013
Great to have you on board.
Lorna Richardson
November 27, 2013
http://digipubarch.org/2013/11/27/why-do-i-blog/
Martin Locock (@mlocock)
November 27, 2013
My thoughts on blogging on archaeological management
http://10simplesteps.blogspot.co.uk/2013/11/why-this-blog-started-and-nearly-stopped.html
Doug Rocks-Macqueen
November 28, 2013
Thanks Martin
samarkeolog
November 28, 2013
Now I’ve confessed my aims, Lorna can study me as a social media fail. 😉 http://unfreearchaeology.wordpress.com/2013/11/27/blogging-archaeology-why/
Doug Rocks-Macqueen
November 28, 2013
LOL
Paul Mullins
November 28, 2013
I’ve added something at http://paulmullins.wordpress.com/2013/11/28/blogging-as-public-archaeology/ though I am pretty confident I did not really answer the question
robertlfs
November 29, 2013
Here is mine: http://rcnnolly.wordpress.com/2013/11/28/why-i-blog/
Kerrie Hoffman
November 29, 2013
I have just finished my contribution, looking at the archaeology of painting http://archaeologyofpainting.blogspot.co.uk/2013/11/why-am-i-blogging.html
Tim Rast
November 29, 2013
From Elfshot: http://elfshotgallery.blogspot.ca/2013/11/blogging-archaeology-why-do-i-blog.html
Patrick Saltonstall
November 30, 2013
I’m not sure if our family blog qualifies as an archaeology blog. But I have noticed that I post a great deal about archaeology, and that if you choose to only look at the archaeology posts I still post more frequently than most other blogs that are exclusive to archaeology. When I am running a dig or survey I post about the project 3 or 4 times a week. Anyway, I guess my point is that I consider my blog an archaeology blog, but it’s not a typical archaeology blog. Or maybe if you just use the blog address with only the archaeological posts linked it is an archaeological blog?
http://saltonstall.blogspot.com/search/label/Archaeology
And because our blog is more of a family blog – the answers to your questions are a bit different than I’ve seen for other archaeological bloggers. I started to blog because my wife made the blog to record our family life. And that is what it basically does. But we still blog because it is way better than a photo album, and we do print out our blog every year or so. Also it forces us to organize our photos. And it helps us to be better writers.
As regards my archaeology posts – I do them because they are a part of my family life. But I have also discovered that they are a form of digital notes. They are my first impression of an ongoing dig. If someone wants to know what we found etc. I usually refer them to my family blog. The museum where I work (the Alutiiq Museum in Kodiak, Alaska) also takes my posts, re works them and re posts them on their website. I have even taken a set of posts and put them together into a ‘preliminary site report’ for the landowner etc. A copy also always gets accessioned with the project notes and collection.
Anyway, not sure If I will post on this on my family blog. But I did want to comment as this is a subject that interests me.
Patrick Saltonstall
titleunderconstruction
November 30, 2013
Great initiative! Just saw it, written my part and paste the link here. It is a blog on theoretical archaeology, bodies and academia- maybe not the traditional archaeology blog. Looking forward to your next questions.
http://titleunderconstruction.wordpress.com/2013/11/30/blogging-archaeology/
Kayt
November 30, 2013
Here’s mine – just before the end of the month! http://girlwithtrowel.wordpress.com/2013/11/30/blogging-archaeology-why-on-earth/
Henry
November 30, 2013
Damn – forgot to include my one – just in time. http://digitaldigging.net/blog/blogging-archaeology-november/
Spencer Carter
December 1, 2013
Does my bum look big in this blog? View from the outside-in | http://microburin.com/2013/12/01/blogging-archaeology-movember-1-bp-why-do-i-blog/
Carl Feagans
December 1, 2013
Better late than never 🙂
Here’s my entry: http://ahotcupofjoe.net/2013/12/blogging-archaeology/
Unearthed
December 2, 2013
Wow! this is such a great idea! going to try get my post in today! 😀
Unearthed
December 2, 2013
Hope I’m not too late. But here is my post on why I blog about archaeology 😀
http://www.unearthedsa.co.za/bitten-archaeology-blogging-bug/
Nicolas Laracuente
December 3, 2013
A short contribution from my new(ish) blog http://bourbonarchaeology.blogspot.com/2013/12/blogging-archaeology-blog-carnival-for.html
Alan S.
December 3, 2013
Creeping in under the wire, very last minute, but we made it! http://heritageaction.wordpress.com/2013/12/03/blogarch-blogging-archaeology/
These Bones Of Mine
December 3, 2013
Little bit late, sorry! http://thesebonesofmine.wordpress.com/2013/12/03/blogging-archaeology-why-i-blog/
Jake F. Pfaffenroth
December 4, 2013
Four years in the making!
http://thenorthamericanist.wordpress.com/2013/12/03/why-blog/
Kayt
December 29, 2013
The pingback seems to have worked, but just in case here is the URL for my december efforts! Happy New Year everyone 🙂 http://girlwithtrowel.wordpress.com/2013/12/29/blogging-archaeology-the-good-the-bad-the-ugly/
Kristina Killgrove (@DrKillgrove)
December 31, 2013
Coming in just under the wire, here are my responses for December, since I’m not sure if the whole pingback thing worked — http://www.poweredbyosteons.org/2013/12/blogging-bioarchaeology-good-bad-ugly.html
darkageology
January 16, 2014
Hello Doug. I did a post answering January’s question:
Great blog by the way!
Dr H
January 26, 2014
Best posts
Katy
January 28, 2014
Should ping back, but just in case – here’s my January post:
darkageology
February 26, 2014
Should ping back, but here’s my February entry. Starting to think about topics for the e-book, and on the general subject of blogging the past as a form of public engagement.
Unearthed
March 31, 2014
Here’s my contribution for March. ‘The Future of Blogging about the Past’
Enjoy, and let me know what you think..
Katrin
March 31, 2014
Here’s my post for March:
http://togs-from-bogs.blogspot.de/2014/03/blog-carnival-last-month.html
Thank you for hosting this – it was great fun to take part!